Monel 400 vs Monel 500: The Ultimate Product Analysis for Industrial Applications

Core Composition and Material Design

Monel 400: Primarily a nickel-copper alloy (67% Ni, 30% Cu, 1-2% Fe), designed for maximum corrosion resistance without precipitation hardening.

Monel K500 (Alloy 500): Adds aluminum (2.3-3.15%) and titanium (0.35-0.85%) to the Monel 400 base. This enables age-hardening for superior strength via Ni₃(Al, Ti) precipitates.

Mechanical Properties Comparison

Table: Key Mechanical Differences

​​​​​​​

Monel K500 offers ~2x higher yield strength but reduced ductility due to age-hardening. Unlike many alloys, K500 avoids brittle fracture even in cryogenic conditions.

Corrosion Resistance and Limitations

Shared Strengths: Both resist seawater, hydrofluoric acid, sulfuric acid, and alkaline environments.

Critical Difference: Monel 400 excels in stress corrosion cracking (SCC) resistance. Monel K500 is susceptible to SCC in certain environments (e.g., acidic sulfides) when age-hardened.

Marine Note: K500’s high strength makes it ideal for pump shafts in flowing seawater, but it may suffer pitting in stagnant seawater.

Applications: Where Each Alloy Shines

Table: Application Suitability

Monel 400: Preferred for welded structures and corrosive fluid containment.

Monel K500: Dominates high-stress components like springs, fasteners, and rotating parts.

Fabrication: Welding and Machining

Welding: Monel 400 is easier to weld (TIG/MIG) with minimal cracking risk. Monel K500 requires strict parameter control to avoid heat-affected zone cracks.

Machining: K500 is best machined in the aged condition (post-hardening) for dimensional stability.

Pricing and Supplier Landscape

Monel K500 Price: ~¥190-215/kg (vs. Monel 400 at ~¥180/kg), reflecting its enhanced properties. 

Strategic Selection Guidelines

Choose Monel 400 when:

• Corrosion resistance is the top priority (e.g., chemical processing).
• Welding or forming ease is critical.

Choose Monel K500 when:

• High strength/hardness is non-negotiable (e.g., pump shafts, fasteners).
• Components operate in low temperatures or abrasive marine environments.

FAQs: Addressing Key Queries

1. Is K Monel the same as Monel 500?
Yes, "K Monel" is a common industry name for Monel K500/500.

2. Why is Monel K500 more expensive?
Its titanium/aluminum content and age-hardening process increase production costs.

3. Can Monel 400 and K500 be used together?
Absolutely. Projects often combine both (e.g., K500 shafts with Monel 400 casings) to leverage dual advantages.